WellBN
01273 772020

Patient Participation Group

 

Goldstone Primary Care Network Patient Participation Group

Aims

  • To give patients and practice staff the opportunity to meet and discuss topics of mutual interest.
  • To provide a means for patients to make suggestions about the healthcare services they receive.
  • To contribute feedback to the practice and explore, propose and monitor improvements, developments and change.
  • To support health awareness and patient education.

Participation

We promote participation and engagement from all members of our diverse patient cohort. 

We will run regular campaigns to encourage patients to take part and to ensure we have representation from all patient cohorts

Goldstone PCN PPG

This is a group of patients from Trinity Surgery, Charter Medical Centre and WellBN who meet every 3 months. 

The group was started in 2022.

To join the group email shilpa.patel14@nhs.net

WellBN Patient Voice

This is our Facebook group which was established in 2018

To join the group click here

WellBN Newsletter

“A dose of WellBN”

To encourage Patient Participation and to share our achievements

Success

Patient Participation Group Webpage

One of our patients recommended we write more about the PPG and share all the information via our website and this has resulted in this webpage.

Join Our PPG 

Article on WellBN Site to encourage patients to join. A link to this article was sent to all patients via Newsletter and 17 new patients signed up to be PPG members!

A very Successful PPG Meeting

We had a very succesful PPG Meeting in December. It was great to meet everyone and to disucss how we would make improvements together in the future. 

WellBN & Goldstone PCN PPG
What are Primary Care Networks (PCNs)

Primary Care Networks, or PCNs, are groups of GP Practices working closely together – along with other healthcare staff and organisations – providing integrated services to the local population. The Goldstone PCN is formed of three local Practices- Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and

WellBN (Brighton Health & Wellbeing Centre and Benfield Valley Healthcare hub).

 

What is a Patient Participation Group?

A Patient Participation Group (PPG) is a group of patients, carers from the PCN community and GP practice staff who meet to discuss practice or PCN issues and patient experience to improve the service. PPGs are defined as ‘critical friends; within the Practice environment, to ensure that services are responsive to patients’ needs.

What are the aims of our PPG?
  • To give patients and practice staff the opportunity to meet and discuss topics of mutual interest.
  • To provide a means for patients to make suggestions about the healthcare services they receive.
  • To contribute feedback to the practice and explore, propose and monitor improvements, developments and change.
  • To support health awareness and patient education.
What can a PPG do?

Discuss constructive suggestions for improving the practice, and share concerns that could affect the wider practice population.

Organise health focused events with the practice, i.e. healthy eating awareness as an information event for all practice patients to attend.

Create a patient survey with practice staff, to get feedback about the practice from the rest of the patient population.

Design a newsletter for the practice, to provide regular updates to patients?

Assist the practice in making sure their website is ‘Patient Friendly’?

Engage with the local community, consider fundraising events, and ensure the PPG is representative.

Invite health and voluntary professionals to PPG meetings, for PPG members to remain informed and updated about local opportunities for patients.

Work with the Social Prescribing Link Workers and Health & Wellbeing Coaches in order to promote group activities and local community links

What can a PPG not do?

PPG patient members cannot provide any medical advice to other patients, or deal with personal/medical issues or individual patient complaints during the meeting. These should be dealt with outside the meeting following the practices already established procedures.

Whilst all constructive suggestions for improving practice will be taken into consideration, PPG members are not decision makers or stakeholders

Who attends the PPG Meetiings?

PPG members should elect a Patient Chair after the first or second meeting. Having a patient who chairs the PPG meetings empowers the group to share their views and encourages co-production between the patients and the practice. The group should also elect a secretary.

There will also be regular representation from the practices either via the Practice Managers or a delegated senior administration team member. GPs can also attend the meetings, either for a regular slot on the agenda, or as and when requested by PPG members. The PPG should aim to meet at least 4 times a year.

What does the chair do?

Manages meetings and is the main link between the patient group and the practice staff.

The Patient Chair should:

Set the agenda of the meeting with a practice representative

Ensure all PPG members have equal opportunity to contribute to the meeting.

Ensure all agenda items are discussed in a timely manner.

Ensure actions are recorded and steps are taken to implement them.

The PPG should also have a Secretary to take the notes of the meeting, as this will help structure the PPG meetings and its activities. This role could rotate amongst the PPG members.

What does the secretary do?

Is responsible for supporting the chair and ensuring the group runs smoothly.

The Secretary should:

  • Take notes at the meeting and circulate them. They should include all action points agreed at the meeting.
  • The notes should be shared using the agreed method of communication for PPG Members; e.g. over email or via post.

Useful Links

Events

Thursday 25th April 2024 6.00-7.30 – PPG Meeting

Thursday 25th January 2024 – PPG Meeting

Thursday 19th October 2023 -PPG Meeting

Wednesday 15th March 2023  – PPG Meeting

7th December 2022 – PPG Meeting

Patient Engagement Campaign via Newsletter

18th Oct 2022 – Patient Sign Up Event at Burwash Reopening Event

16th Oct 2022 – PPG Article on WellBN site – Join our PPG

15th Sept 2022 – PPG Meeting

Recommendations

Make a PPG Webpage – Completed

Improve the website – Ongoing – PPG members offered to help and a full review will take place from June 2023 as there is possibly  funding available towards this.

Share articles – these have been shared on home page of website and in newsletters

Promote WellBN Social Prescribing  Explain what it is Who is it for How can patients avail this service – Dr Laura Marshall Andrews and Emma Drew are working on updating the complimentary, alternative, HERA and socila prescribeing website pages.

Send out patient feedback forms – It was decided we would use the the national patient survey and we cannot promote this. 

Set up Friends and Family Feedback – FFT was set up 1st Feb 2023 and a big push on google reviews 

GP contract information to be shared – changes once more information available and how the contract works n- Pending

 

2024 Meetings

Meeting Agenda 25th April 2024

Welcome– KH – 5 mins – new members

· Introductions and any conflicts of interest – KH – 5 mins

· Actions/minutes/sub groups last meeting – KH -10 minutes

· Group project updates – 15 minutes

· Tanya Petherick – Governor Sussex Community Foundation Trust – 30 minutes

· Practice updates – 10 minutes

· Suggested topics for next meeting – 5 mins

Meeting Notes 25th January 2024

Staff present:
Lindsay Coleman-Lead Partner at WellBN
Nina Graham Managing Partner at Charter
Gemma Clayton-Primary Care Network Manager
Kate Heath – PPG volunteer – Patient Chair
Kate Heath opened the meeting welcomed new members, introductions and any conflicts of interest
Dr Ahmad – GP at Trinity and Clinical Director for Goldstone PCN answered a number of questions from the group. To note – these answers were Dr Ahmad’s personal views and thoughts

From Neil

What would be the 3 policies or changes that you would implement straightaway (quick wins) to improve the NHS?
Access to Diagnostics, CT scans and MRI – would like direct access rather than referring to the
hospital, some parts of the country now have this access but not many. Could improve waiting lists and patient experience. Imaging provided by a number of providers on behalf of the NHS not just hospital trusts. Hospitals would argue that GPs don’t necessarily know what type of tests to order.

Quick win and long term win is access to Mental Health – we haven’t got places/services to send
patients – very complex will be in care but there are very complex patients looked after by primary care and numerous consultations and not necessary an outcome – from teenagers right up. Services could include talking therapies/ group/ support therapies that don’t need to be under a psychiatrist.

Hospital secretaries – access to talk to someone at the hospital – e.g talk to consultants/find our
results – GPs don’t have hot line/access. Improve communications with hospital. Patients then
contact practice

Longer Term – work force my view never heard of a workforce plan – main issue – retention is the
issue not the actual recruitment. E.g start at medical school and then 7/8 years later junior doctor and don’t maybe want to be one anymore. Issues both a junior or as an experienced doctor no incentive to stay. Not attracting students from abroad and the nursing degree now required and more can be earnt in other careers. Not attracting GPs as have before, overseas graduates
expressing more interest in General Practice – but quite difficult as UK/New Zealand have GP practice model but other countries don’t have the same services. Also working practices for clinicians has changed. GPs not working 5 days a week having portfolio careers and want a work life balance and GPs working lots harder than it was 15/20 years ago – complexities, expectations so much harder. The work has moved from outpatients into general practice and work is more intense.

Different expectations now from hospital and general practice – work pushed into general practice – so now patient has operation and would have gone to outpatients and now directed to GP.

Question was asked re patient behaviour – it is the front staff that get the complaints directly rather than the GPs. There is a disparity between funding – 8/9% primary care of the funding budget – without primary care the rest of NHS would be unsupported.

Question re retention of staff in practice and discussion re numbers of staff in the practices now.
More staff in general practice than ever before and trying to ensure that the roles are mixed so that staff aren’t always on the front reception and can be skilled in other areas but also trying to make the role less stressful.

Question re call back service at WellBN – this is on way – contract work happening. National target that practices measured on, so large programme of work so providers doing in order.
Discussion re patient access – face to face verses phone call. There are benefits of phone access – e.g no parking/travel, short appointment and appointments more likely to be on time – useful for bloods results etc. It could make it easier for some patients. Relies on common sense approach so if patients booking in on phone but actually need face to face can end of taking another appointment as need to see, so need to be careful that patients are seen face to face when they need to be. So have online booking – patients do themselves – e consults then can triage. Only certain amount of appointments that can book into. Practices try and ensure that patients are seen by the same clinician so consistent.

Discussion re general health/ cost of living and life style – examples of what we tackle and then other issues e.g vaping impact in future

Question re services after Covid getting up and running – practices were open during this time, huge impact on waiting list now/out patients impact. Learning from Covid in terms of technology

From Leslie
Assuming we have a majority labour government in the autumn of 2024, what does he expect in terms of changes to GP practices, health and social care within the first five years of the new government?

Wes Streeting ( Shadow secretary of state for Health & Social Care) – not so keen on GP
partnerships. One of his plans is to try to make GP partnerships a thing of the past. Looking at
structure of the partnerships. Changes already happening because newer GPs will become salaried as don’t necessarily want the responsibilities. GPs currently have two roles – clinical/ managing the practice. Costs if run differently e.g. by a hospital will be higher. Discussion re GPs knowing patients if run differently.

How will GP services, health and social services deal with the dramatic change in potential new patients as a result of the exponential number of new apartment blocks that have been created throughout Brighton and Hove?

Yes a concern, infrastructure not considered in terms of new housing and healthcare and how
General Practice will manage. At Trinity rooms already fully utilised so will be difficult with new
buildings.

Neil asked doctor friends what they though re NHS and how they would change things

Short term, IT standard system, Standardised treatment, Reduce NHS remit, Longer term
Retain and recruit, , reverse privatisation, Get right infrastructure, Public health services

Charlotte question
Is Covid and Long Covid is impact still being seen?
Funding to support the care has now all gone. Long Covid service in place. More sickness in
practices. In GP practices have to be responsible so if staff have Covid – work at home/ swap staff
around so not infectious for patients etc.

Actions/minutes/sub groups last meeting in October
Email addresses sent out to Michael and others plus the internet framework
Kate – no progress yet with patient engagement work
Michael – has only seen one written report from Jon Carling – and has seen framework – thanks to
Jon and Leslie also for website feedback. Group fed back that they hadn’t heard from Michael –
agreed we would follow up when Michael at next meeting.
Actions – follow up with Jon re engagement form/ follow up with Jo re Charter website and Digital
Manager link up. SCFT patient group – Kate to link up and invite to the next meeting

Garden project update
Leslie met with Lindsay in October. Worked for 4 mornings for each week in the month of
November. Lots achieved and still need lots of work to improve.
Leslie would like the work to be able to continue without him. Lindsay thanked Leslie – really
fantastic effort to do and has made great progress . Lindsay asked if Leslie in the next year could set up a group and help and teach others. If there is a group with a plan then others would eb very encouraged. Suggestion that the group put up a poster – needs to be the PPG that lead this. Leslie wanted to access and use specialist skills to begin with but to sustain this need others.
Lindsay very happy for posters to go up. Keith volunteered to create a poster and to liaise with Keith re contact details. Leslie would want a commitment by volunteers of a couple of hours a week – mornings and check weather forecast – Leslie would contact volunteers. Equipment – volunteers could bring basic tools /tools can be provided also by Lindsay. Suggested that we share information about the garden with social prescribers / health coaches

Actions –
Gemma to share email addresses with Keith/Mary and Leslie
Keith to design poster
Gemma to share poster with social prescribers and health coaches

Question re practices and access to on line services
Response from Trinity
Data is based on current Trinity List of 24,021
Includes any patients who have any degree of online access, this could be just to book appointments or order medication, all the way up to patients with full coded note access. This includes people who use 3rd party apps to order medication, like the Lloyds online app.

1. Total number of patients who have applied for online access is 14,052 (58%), total number
who have activated it to use it is 12,437 (52%)
2. Total patients who have set up the NHS app are 10, 905 (out of 52% who are active -88%
patients have set up NHS app)
3. Total number of patients with no form of online access is 9, 969 (42%)

Practice updates :
Trinity
Dr Chloe Jagger has started 12 month maternity leave- welcomed her third child, a another
boy, 3 weeks early. Mum and baby doing well. Her leave is being covered by Dr Rob
Coddington who has already been working for Trinity for a number of months. Dr Jo Ratcliff
will be starting her maternity leave from 29th February and will be off until April 2025. Her
leave will be covered by Dr Fiona Bell Ringer who you may already be familiar with, as she
used to work here as a salaried doctor and has done many recent locum shifts for us since
her return from Australia.

WellBN
Successful Advent calendar project – each of the days designed by staff and voluntary groups the
practice works with. Each day had health and wellbeing topic and scene to look at as well as more
information/ website/ QR code. Could be seen inside the practice and in the window.
Phone answering initiative Trigger point 10 – if more than 10 people in phone queue – other staff
help to answer calls idea is to get waiting time down to 12-13 minutes.

Charter
Charter has recently commenced participation in the General Practice Improvement
Programme, the team are looking at how to “support access” through:-
1. Use & Understanding of Demand & Capacity Data
2. Use of Online Consultation Systems
3. Use of Care Navigation
The Programme runs for 13 weeks and is supported by external facilitation by an approved
NHSE consultancy.
Charter is currently trialling automated workflow AI software to improve the turnaround
time for clinical correspondence and non clinical work flow. The trial will last for three
months and will hopefully address recruitment gaps in the administrative team.

Lastly, we have been working through the NHSE national standards for website suppliers
and have identified a new supplier. We will be in contact with PPG members regarding this.
Date for next meeting Thursday 25th April 6-7.30

Meeting Agenda 25th January 2024

Welcome– KH – 5 mins – new members

 

· Introductions and any conflicts of interest – KH – 5 mins

 

· Dr Nad Ahmad – GP at Trinity and Clinical Director for Goldstone PCN – 45 mins

 

· Actions/minutes/sub groups last meeting – KH -10 minutes

 

· Group project updates – 15 minutes

 

· Practice updates – sent with minutes

 

· Suggested topics for next meeting – 5 mins

Meeting Notes 19th October 2024

Nina Graham had sent apologies for non attendance, and had asked Gemma
Clayton to feedback to her re any actions for Charter.
The register of attendance by PPG members at the meeting is as follows:
Kate Heath (Chair) Trinity Patient. Leslie Holland (note taker) Charter Patient ,Nagi
Giloda, Neil Henderson.Coreen Sears, Subhash Kar, Nina Patel, John Carling ,Ron
DeWitt, Keith Mason, Mary Mason, Michael Creedy
Agenda
Welcome and brief introduction by Gemma Clayton.
Congratulations to Kate Heath regarding her recent marriage.
Welcome also to new members of the PPG.
Introductions by staff present, and in addition by Kate Heath and Leslie Holland
Kate Heath chaired the remainder of the meeting.
Actions/minutes/subgroups from last meeting in June 2023.
To set up sub committees to review websites/patient information.
Kate Heath had sent out an earlier e-mail, through Gemma Clayton, outlining the
small group required to regularly review practice websites (Trinity, Charter and
WellBN) and feedback to the practices suggestions for improvement. For example
testing of the websites for accessibility, ease of identifying services (sign posting),
including appointment booking. The sub committee will help create a place for the
PPG to have a presence on line.
Amanda Jones updated the group regarding the Trinity website. It uses an NHS
contents list (Useful in audit trail). NHS England dictates the content of website.
It was agreed that websites require simple language, simple fonts and to avoid
acronyms.
ACTION;
Practice managers agreed to feedback to the PPG group the approx. number of
patients who were able to contact the practices using digital tools for a follow up
discussion re digital access if that information was available
The reviewed websites need to emphasise how patients can book appointments and
to order prescriptions.
Leslie Holland had reviewed the Charter Medical Centre website in July 2023 and
had fed-back improvement comment regarding this website to Gemma and Kate.
Gemma had shared this information with Nina Graham at Charter. To date Leslie
has received no communication from Nina.
Leslie also reviewed 6 other PPG websites. 2 of them, i.e. The Brighton and Hove
PPG network and the Links Road surgery were active and useful. The others, e.g.
the Park Crescent Centre; Regency Surgery; St.Peter`s Health Centre and the
Warmdene Surgery were not truly active or useful.
Leslie noted that the Charter, Trinity and WellBN had links to PPG information.
WellBN had the greater information regarding the PPG.
One or two other people in our group had feedback information to Kate Heath, but no
information was shared regarding their findings.
Kate Heath suggested that surgery screens could supply patient information,
however, patient literacy and differences in common language may limit the reach of
this form of communication.
Coreen Sears urged caution in managing patient expectations regarding the website
review.
Neil Henderson expressed some concerns about our PPG reviewing the websites.
His concerns were re duplication of work and using examples of good websites that
were already out there.
The 5 Goldstone surgeries are not a consortium and require different websites.
Project group 1
The initial Website sub committee names are as follows:
Michael Creedy (lead the group)
Coreen Sears ,John Carling, Subhash Kar, Keith Mason, Ron DeWitt, Charlotte Feld
Others within the PPG may choose to join this group who weren’t at the meeting
ACTIONs ;
• The names of the volunteers to be shared with Michael,
• Michael be provided with all the website feedback so that he can share it with
the focus group,
• Michael to provide an outline of how the group will operate
(meetings/communications etc),
• Areas they intend to focus on a timeline (quarterly?) on how they will
feedback progress to the PPG,
• Proposal on how they will engage with the practices IT/web staff to implement
any improvements.
• PPG Webpage – how will it be implemented across the three practices and
kept up to date (it will need a specific owner)
Project group 2
Kate Heath`s second recommended sub committee involved members of the PPG
interacting with patients at clinics, e.g. flu clinics, to promote the PPG and gather
patient feedback either verbally or through simple patients questionnaires regarding
services at the respective practices. The group will agree how often this information
is shared with the practices through the PPG meeting.
Mary Mason had performed this function with a previous PPG group with a good
result achieved with Lindsay Colman at WellBN. Discretion, preparation and
sensitivity were important attributes in this activity.
Amanda) thought it too late in the year for PPG members to engage in flu clinics for
2023 as many patients had already been vaccinated in all practices within the
Goldstone group. Planning towards these begins a year in advance. The clinics are
promoted at the Trinity Centre through differing forms of communication, e.g. in
person, by telephone, by text, on-line, etc. Approx 60 Trinity patients opted to be
vaccinated at a Pharmacy.
Kate Heath asked: how did surgeries monitor the success of vaccination. Data is
monitored and a vaccine order is placed through the practices. When these ordered
vaccines are all consumed the practice feels that the service has satisfied its
patients. More vaccines can be obtained should more patients require this service.
The flu vaccine is at a cost to the practice. The practice is not allowed to charge
patients directly. National government need to address anomalies in vaccine
ordering, i.e. the vaccines ordered are not necessarily used, and therefore the British
taxpayer shares the cost of the system.
GP practices have no influence over external pharmacies, even when the
pharmacies are on the same site as the practice, e.g. Charter and Trinity as they are
separate businesses
GP practices do not vaccinate against Covid .
Kate Heath sought volunteers for the second committee group – patient interaction
group. Ron DeWitt and Coreen Sears expressed an interest in being part of this
group. Others are encouraged to join the group. Kate will lead this group
ACTIONs;
• Mary has offered to provide guidance and support, and Kate to have a go at
putting together a ‘PPG marketing plan’,
• If any future campaigns to be shared in advance with PPG, then I can plan
how we can go about including a PPG representative or two,
• What spaces are available in the practices to advertise the PPG and an
events suggestions box – who should we be inviting to come and speak to
patients about the services on offer.
• As with the other groups, plans to be shared at the next PPG.
Project group 3
Kate Heath`s third recommended subcommittee involved contact from the
“Burwash” garden to request the Goldstone PPG to assist in “tidying” up the practice
garden. Kate thought this a good opportunity to promote the PPG group and for the
sub committee to bond during this activity.
Leslie Holland agreed to lead on this. Gemma to share details with Leslie on who to
contact. Leslie would contact the Burwash member of staff to arrange a meeting at
the location and assess the help required. Leslie would also be grateful to receive
information from Lindsay Coleman as to a budget allocation for the garden
maintenance.
Following the Burwash meeting Leslie would feedback to Kate Heath and Gemma as
to the meeting outcome and the possible need to recruit further volunteers from
within the Goldstone PPG.
ACTIONs ;
• Leslie’s outline plan to be shared with the PPG and a request for volunteers.
• A summary of the plan
o A 7m x 5m space that was landscaped, and plants were added in
2022 but has since become overgrown,
o Access to the garden is through the surgery. The surgery needs to be
notified in advance when volunteers intend to come and work on the
garden,
o There is no formal budget available but the costs for removing garden
rubbish will be met by the surgery,
o There are some basic tools, volunteers should also bring their own,
o Lesley will begin some work this winter, a larger group of volunteers
will be required from the beginning of March onwards for a few hours
a week.
This is a great project to help those who would benefit from being out and about a bit
as part of their care or rehabilitation. It would be good if WellBN could engage with
groups to let them know our activity. Those groups could then engage with the PPG if
they have people who would benefit from volunteering.
Further Q&A`s from the meeting.
Neil Henderson asked how many GP`s were active at each surgery and how many
patients were allocated to a GP. Amanda from the Trinity said that 16 GP`s were
registered with the Trinity, and she thought that the Charter had a similar number.
The WellBN practice had less than 16 GP`s.
Nina Patel shared her recent experience at the Trinity practice. There was an issue
with a staff member not introducing themselves to Nina during a conversation and
the clinical role that they had. It was agreed that Amanda would address this matter
with the surgery.
Practice updates
Amanda Jones reported that the newly installed patient ring-back service (since 7th
July 2023) had performed well and had received good feedback from patients.
The Trinity continued to experience admin. recruitment difficulties.
Amanda is happy to discuss the CQC (Care Quality Commission) at future meetings.
Lindsay Colman had received positive feedback from the recent CQC (Care Quality
Commission) inspection at WellBN
No report received from Nina Graham as Nina is on annual leave. Gemma
informed us that Nina would prefer to feedback in person at the next meeting.
Update on the Healthwatch meeting from Kate Heath. Kate has not received any
information from the organisation.
GP contracts in place until 2024.
A question from Ron DeWitt to the practice managers. Could the Goldstone GP
practices manage contractual obligations differently from one another. Amanda
(Trinity) responded saying that there would need to be PCN group agreement.
ACTION;
A note taker is needed for the next PPG meeting in January 2024. Please feedback
to Gemma/Kate if you are interested in this task
Suggested topic for next meeting:
GP perspective on how the service has changed in recent years, i.e. NHS England
perspective. To invite a GP to the next meeting
The next Goldstone PPG will be 25th January at Trinity Medical Centre 6.00-7.30

Meeting Agenda 19th october 2024

Welcome– GC – 5 mins

· Introductions – KH – 10 mins

· Actions/minutes/sub groups last meeting – KH -30 minutes

· Practice updates – Practice Managers- 15 mins

· Update on Healthwatch meeting – KH – 5 mins

· Suggested topics for next meeting – 5 mins

· Agreement re email addresses

 

 

2023 Meetings

Meeting Notes 14th June 2023

Time: 6.00pm – 7.30pm
Location: Trinity Medical Centre/ MSTeams
For those new to the meeting – Goldstone Patient participation group is made up of three practices – Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and WellBN (Brunswick site, Benfield Valley Healthcare hub site and Burwash site).
The practice representatives are;
Lindsay Coleman – Lead Partner at WellBN
Nina Graham – Managing Partner at Charter Medical Centre
Amanda Jones – Practice Manager at Trinity Medical Centre
Gemma Clayton Primary care Network Manager
Chair – Kate Heath and note taker Nicola Thomas – both Trinity patients
The Handbook and Terms of Reference have been sent out and printed copies shared at the initial meeting and this can be shared again.
Key points from the handbook

Aims and Objectives
To give patients and practice staff the opportunity to meet and discuss topics of mutual
interest.
To provide a means for patients to make suggestions about the healthcare services they receive.
To contribute feedback to the practice and explore, propose and monitor improvements,
developments and change.
To support health awareness and patient education.

What can a PPG do?
Discuss constructive suggestions for improving the practice, and share concerns that could
affect the wider practice population.
Organise health focused events with the practice, i.e. healthy eating awareness as an information
event for all practice patients to attend.
Create a patient survey with practice staff, to get feedback about the practice from the rest of
the patient population.
Design a newsletter for the practice, to provide regular updates to patients?
Assist the practice in making sure their website is ‘Patient Friendly’?
Engage with the local community, consider fundraising events, and ensure the PPG is
representative.
Invite health and voluntary professionals to PPG meetings, for PPG members to remain informed
and updated about local opportunities for patients.
Work with the Social Prescribing Link Workers and Health & Wellbeing Coaches in order to
promote group activities and local community links

What can a PPG not do?
PPG patient members cannot provide any medical advice to other patients, or deal with
personal/medical issues or individual patient complaints during the meeting. These should be
dealt with outside the meeting following the practices already established procedures.
Whilst all constructive suggestions for improving practice will be taken into consideration, PPG
members are not decision makers or stakeholders

Agenda
• Welcome by the Chair Kate Heath and Gemma Clayton Primary Care Network Manager
• New and existing members of the PPG introduced themselves with a brief background of their lives
and their motivation for wishing to be a member of this PPG.
Actions/minutes from last meeting
• Current GP contract information when available; All 3 practices to share top and bottom feedback
results, such as Friends and Family. It was agreed that the PPG need to understand what patient
issues were in order to help the practices. This information may lead to the beginnings of a PPG
subcommittee group which could “drill down” further into these issues and support service
improvement to the service.
Practice Partner/ Manager Updates
Amanda Jones-Trinity Medical Centre Practice Manager
Amanda discussed work undertaken to enhance the patient telephone system. She hoped that the patient
call back system would be available by the middle of July 23.
Amanda stated that the Practice website had been enhanced, and in her opinion was more user friendly.
She mentioned that unfortunately 2 zero tolerance letters had been issued to patients, however, she was
pleased to state that 14 compliments towards the service had been received in the previous 3 months.
Nina Graham-Charter Medical Centre Managing Partner
Nina discussed improvements made by the new Digital Transformation Manger and the role of the NHS App
as one of the methods by which patients could access services.
Nina mentioned that website enhancement had been ongoing for some months.
She discussed the newly appointed Reception Manager Role (5 weeks in) and this Manager`s involvement
in the phone hub.
Nina discussed the surgery compliments feedback process in the first 3 months of 2023.
Nina mentioned that winter waiting patient times had been prolonged mainly due to staff shortage/illness
Lindsay Coleman – Lead Partner at WellBN
Lindsay discussed the challenges she had faced from the merger of various practices into the current
WellBN. During this period a CQC inspection had sent somewhat critical assessment of the newly merged
WellBN, but a recent CQC assessment had been verbally much more complimentary of the service. Lindsay
awaits the written report and will share it with the PPG once received.
Update on Healthwatch meeting
Kate updated on the meeting which brought together members of the PPGs across Brighton & Hove with
Healthwatch. Healthwatch are developing a report with recommendations from the event for PPGs but
this is not yet available and remains an item for the next PPG meeting.
3
Actions from meeting
Date Action Who Target

 

Meeting Agenda 15th March 2023

Presentation – Social Prescribing
Emma Drew – CEO Robin Hood Foundation spoke about the work the organisation do with the
PCN – presentation included with the notes.
PPG members engaged with the presentation and the key points/concerns put to Emma with
responses were:
• Value and purpose of social prescribing in helping patients address health issues. It isn’t
an alternative to GP services but part of a bigger holistic view of healthcare.
• SP is only for people over 18, what is offered to younger people? Funding request to plug
this gap denied.
• Is SP rationed as a service? A balanced approach to demand is used for delivery of the
service.
• Do SPs work with other groups/signpost to other services? Yes.
• How is a person referred to SP? This can come from various avenues not just GPs
Actions/minutes from last meeting
Discussion re surveys and value and what actions taken and were patients listened to and was
feedback actually used and when changes were made were patients informed.
Nina Graham talked through Friends and Family text with option of free text and responses
received. Charter patient commented that this had happened after appointment and had fed
back. This information is then reported on quarterly at Charter partner meeting. It was asked why
all the practices weren’t doing this way. Each practice in Goldstone PCN uses Friends and Family
text but not the option for free text. Amanda Jones to discuss with Nina Graham.
A question arose re GDPR ( General data protection regulations) and contacting patients –
Amanda Jones explained that patients could be contacted if direct patient care but otherwise
can’t be contacted for things like PPG unless signed up on patient registration forms as classed as
‘direct marketing’.
Date Action Who Target Date Complete
07.12.22 To circulate criteria by which
web developers get on to
the preferred supplier list
Nina Graham End of year attached to
December email
Shared
07.12.22 To provide link to the GPAD
data
Gemma
Clayton
End of year attached to
December email
Shared
07.12.22 Submit feedback to Trinity
Medical re their website and
new requests to go on the
website
Group End of Feb ‘23 Shared and feedback
received
07.12.22 Volunteer expertise, if
available, re questionnaire
design
Group End of Jan ‘23 Discussed at meeting
16.03.23 – practices
using Friends and
Family text messages
07.12.22 Volunteer as survey Guinea
Pigs
Group End of Jan ‘23 n/a as survey work
didn’t happen
07.12.22 Circulate New Patient Pack
from WellBN
Shilpa Patel End of Jan ‘23 n/a pack is staff pack
not patient pack – (
updated after
checking with Shilpa)
07.12.22 Follow up with
Commissioners re updated
“Roles in GP practice leaflet
for Brighton”
Gemma
Clayton
ongoing Completed and
attached to December
email
Practice Managers/Partners to talk through what happening in practices
Amanda Jones, Trinity
• Short trial phase re Accurx to replace econsult system. Short timescales to make a decision re
using this system – information re changes shared with patients via texts and posters in waiting
rooms. Feedback from those in the room was that the new form so much easier to use and
don’t have to fill in as much information.
• Telephony upgrade
This has been delayed by NHSE but hoping to go live May time
• Website
Changes have been made – patient feedback taken into consideration. Patient feedback at the
meeting said website clunky, too many colours, should have tabs at top and that staff groups
not on site. Staff groups in section – about us Our Staff « Trinity Medical Centre
(trinitymedicalcentrehove.co.uk)
• Additional Capacity
Extra remote GP appointments available using GPDQ – not suitable for those that need Face to
face and aimed at new conditions not existing. Patients have been made aware of this new
option
• Reception Desk Screens
How do patients feel if these are taken down? Staff would like that to happen – group very
positive about taking down and agreed would be a good thing to happen
Nina Graham, Charter
1
st April moving to ACCRX patient contact form rather than e consult
• IT Digital Manager recruited to start at Charter and then to work across the PCN practices
• 2 new GPs recruited to and a Reception Manager recruitment process currently happening
• Enhanced access/ services provided 6-8 and at weekends. Currently provided by organisation
called HERE but being brought back to the GP practices to manage from 1st April with support
from all the PCNs in Brighton & Hove and the Brighton & Hove GP Federation.
About Us (brightonandhovefed.co.uk)
• Charter website – feedback given at meeting that social prescribing not on site – social
prescribers mentioned under staff at practice – Our Staff – Charter Medical Centre but not a
specific area
Lindsay Coleman, WellBN –
• Changes to the current GP contract as requested by the meeting chair as item . This was a general
item for discussion which WellBN agreed to discuss in their update slot. Practices were currently
waiting for more information re access to services and what the information means as well as other
updates to the contract. There was some discussion re this item and what information had been
share by the media and what patients in the room had heard. Agreed to bring update to next
meeting when available., WellBN were prepared to discuss it under their update.
• CQC update – LC was asked where the practice was re the CQC. After the initial CQC report the
practice were given actions to follow up on and have now had an interim report which was good
and CQC happy that work had been done. A further visit is due which will include Benfield as newly
merged – waiting for new date. Once CQC completed will be on the WellBN website.

Meeting Notes 15th March 2023

Goldstone PPG Meeting
Notes / Action Log
Date: Wednesday 15th March
Time: 6.00pm – 8.00pm
Location: Trinity Medical Centre and via MS Teams
Location: Trinity Medical Centre/ MSTeams
For those new to the meeting – Goldstone Patient participation group is made up of three practices
Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and WellBN (Brunswick site, Benfield Valley Healthcare hub
site and Burwash site).
The practice representatives are;
Lindsay Coleman – Lead Partner at WellBN
Nina Graham – Managing Partner at Charter Medical Centre
Amanda Jones – Practice Manager at Trinity Medical Centre
Gemma Clayton Primary care Network Manager
Chair – Kate Heath and note taker Nicola Thomas – both Trinity patients
The Handbook and Terms of Reference have been sent out and printed copies shared at the initial meeting
and this can be shared again.
Key points from the handbook
Aims and Objectives
To give patients and practice staff the opportunity to meet and discuss topics of mutual
interest.
To provide a means for patients to make suggestions about the healthcare services they receive.
To contribute feedback to the practice and explore, propose and monitor improvements,
developments and change.
To support health awareness and patient education.
What can a PPG do?
Discuss constructive suggestions for improving the practice, and share concerns that could
affect the wider practice population.
Organise health focused events with the practice, i.e. healthy eating awareness as an information
event for all practice patients to attend.
Create a patient survey with practice staff, to get feedback about the practice from the rest of
the patient population.
Design a newsletter for the practice, to provide regular updates to patients?
Assist the practice in making sure their website is ‘Patient Friendly’?
Engage with the local community, consider fundraising events, and ensure the PPG is
representative.
Invite health and voluntary professionals to PPG meetings, for PPG members to remain informed
and updated about local opportunities for patients.
Work with the Social Prescribing Link Workers and Health & Wellbeing Coaches in order to
promote group activities and local community links
What can a PPG not do?
PPG patient members cannot provide any medical advice to other patients, or deal with
personal/medical issues or individual patient complaints during the meeting. These should be
dealt with outside the meeting following the practices already established procedures.
Whilst all constructive suggestions for improving practice will be taken into consideration, PPG
members are not decision makers or stakeholders

2022 Meetings

Meeting Agenda 7th December 2022

Goldstone Primary Care Network

Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and WellBN (Brighton Health & Wellbeing Centre and Benfield Valley Healthcare hub)

 

Patient Participation Community Group Agenda

Date: Wednesday 7th December 2022

Time: 5.00pm – 7.00pm

Location: Trinity Medical Centre/ MSTeams

 

 

Agenda

 

 

  • Welcome to Goldstone Primary Care Network GC then handover to Chair KH

 

  • Introduction for new group members – Chair

 

  • Practice Managers/Partners to talk through what happening in practices and what support they would like– 30 min – Practice Managers/All

 

  • Actions from last meeting – GC

 

  • Video clip – GC/All

 

  • Frequency of future meetings Chair/All

Meeting Notes 7th December 2022

Goldstone Primary Care Network (PCN)

Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and WellBN (Brighton Health & Wellbeing Centre and Benfield Valley Healthcare hub)

Patient Participation Community Group (PPG)Agenda

Date: Wednesday 7th December 2022

Time: 5.00pm – 7.00pm

Location: Trinity Medical Centre/ MSTeams

Minutes

  1. Welcome to Goldstone Primary Care Network.
  • Practice managers introduced.

Lindsay Coleman Practice Lead and Partner WellBN

Shilpa Patel Lead Pharmacist & Partner WellBN

Nina Graham Managing Partner Charter Medical centre

Amanda James Practice Manager Trinity Medical centre

Gemma Clayton PCN Manager gemma.clayton@nhs.net

Kate Heath Chair

  • Handbook and terms of reference distributed. Attention drawn to the Ground rules section of the leaflet as a reminder of the mutual commitments.
  • Request from the room to open a door and improve air circulation ref Covid etc.
  1. Actions from last meeting
  • See table below
  • A question had been raised at the previous meeting regarding “Roles in a GP practice” and Gemma had found a document from a previous area with that information. Gemma had spoken to the Brighton commissioners to update the document for Brighton so it could be distributed to practices. It could be shared in new patient packs, on websites and print outs in practices.
  1. Introduction for new group members

As the group was large and there were some time constraints, it was decided to simply indicate by show of hands how many group members were from each practice to be done after the practice managers / partners talks:

Charter 2 ; WellBN 12; Trinity 3

Thanks were given to Shilpa (WellBN) for her work in drawing in new group members.

 

  1. Practice Managers/Partners to talk through what happening in practices

Amanda James, Trinity Medical

  • Trinity have been invited by the Integrated care board to consider different web providers. Amanda requested feedback on the current website and ideas for things people would like to see on a practice website. Submission of the requested work would be Feb 2023 and it was estimated the new website should be up and running by April 2023. Feedback was requested sooner rather than later, though it would be accepted at any time. Feedback to be submitted via email to Gemma.
  • Trinity medical will implement a phone system upgrade. NHS digital wants all GP practices to go to a cloud based system. The new system would include a call ring back service that patients could use so they don’t need to remain in long hold queues. Notification of the new system would be made by: Notice in the practice; notice on the web page; text message to those who have agreed to receive such messages. Q. How to reach patients who are not internet / mobile users?
  • Trinity would like to run a patient survey and Amanda invited questions that the group felt might be useful on such a survey. To be submitted via email to Gemma.

Nina Graham, Charter Medical

  • Nina commented that Charter Medical had added a third question to their Friends & Family test requesting “Any Feedback”. Nina was concerned that, so far, the feedback had not been great.
  • Phase II of works was underway creating more space to facilitate growth. Charter were expecting their patient numbers to hit 30,000 by the end of the year. Phase II would include the created of a clinical hub space to enable multidisciplinary working. Q. How to maintain patient confidentiality in such an environment. Nina will bear that in mind when setting up the space next year, but it would certainly include telephone headsets.

 

Lindsay Coleman, WellBN

  • Lindsay wanted to update the group regarding a data gathering exercise by Department of Health (DoH), known as GPAD, where national data would be gathered from GP appointment systems to create a league table based on 3 main questions. This league table was to address a question of “patient satisfaction with access”.
    • No of GP Appointments vs other appointments
    • Total No of appointments per 100k ( a statistical measure)
    • Time of appointment being logged vs time the patient was seen

Lindsay pointed out that such a league table may give false views if taken in isolation, e.g. it would be easy to increase the no of appointments per 100K by shortening appointment times and move up the league table but would this actually be an improvement?

Q. Can practices or patients feedback to the DoH that this is not useful?

Q. What can PPG group do to help mitigate any perceived detriment resulting from this survey?

Q. Will practices be doing a huge amount of work to “fix” reputational damage and if so what’s really in it for the patient? However patient surveys focusing on practice improvements for staff and patients are still useful.

 

There was discussion around patient surveys, web communications, talking to friends and family etc., but concluding opinion was that spending too much time on such “fixing reputation” activities was not in the interests of patients.

Q. Can surveys and results be used to bid for funding if service provision gaps are identified? Maybe if funding is available down the line.

  • Lindsay invited the group to volunteer if they (or they knew anyone who) had experience of questionnaire design in order to avoid leading questions and unconscious bias in creating questionnaires. Volunteers to guinea pig questionnaires were also invited.
  • Practices were cautioned against using surveys as Vanity Projects and the group invited the PCN to consider aligning the practice patient survey across the 3 practices.
  • It was noted that the government GP Practice survey was due in January and not to confuse this with surveys by individual practices. A comment was made about the dangers of Feedback Fatigue. Only a small proportion of patients ever reply. Q. how to get feedback from a broad representation of patients and be inclusive of those who don’t have digital access
  • As part of the discussion it came up that WellBN had designed a New Patient Pack which had positive feedback from the practice. Shilpa was invited to share this pack with the PPG group. The group invited the practices to ensure accessibility for such information e.g. languages, disabilities, people with little or no access to social media.
  • It was commented that a group member had googled “Goldstone PCN” and only Trinity came up.
  1. Video clip

This was a fairly simple but interesting video about how the NHS is organised in England and can be found on the Kingsfund website

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/how-does-nhs-in-england-work

other info can be found at

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/explain

Q. Would it be useful to have a link to this on practice websites?

 

  1. Frequency of future meetings.
  • To be roughly quarterly unless issues came up such that an interim meetings would be useful. Smaller action groups could meet as required if they were set up.
  • Q. Would a WhatsApp group be useful? – Maybe for the smaller action groups and not everyone has a smart phone / WhatsApp.
  • Remote access to future meetings to continue.

Any other Business

  • Attention was drawn to the last page of the PPG handbook where it states that copies of minutes were to be shared with practice managers for distribution to practice staff and to be made available to patients as appropriate. Q. How this was to be done? Draft minutes would be submitted to Gemma and Kate. Final minutes would be circulated to the practice managers by Gemma . Practices would make printed copies available in reception and consider adding a link on the PPG part of their respective webpages. There is also a PPG notice board in Trinity practice and possibly in the other two practices as well.
  • A comment from the group was made regarding the success of a social prescribing event “Goldstone Real Food”. It became clear that social prescribing was a fairly unknown subject in the patient group. Q. Does social prescribing have to go through the GP? Not necessarily, some aspects can be self-referred. It was concluded that social prescribing should be more widely promoted and events made more widely known, especially to patients who are digitally challenged and who may be the patients who could benefit the most from these services. No specific actions came out of this, but maybe this could be on the agenda for the next meeting or a sub group formed for this specific subject.

Actions

Date

Action

Who

Target Date

Complete

15.09.22

To send out email to group of attendees – to confirm next steps/Action plan

Gemma Clayton

YES

15.09.22

Agree date for next meeting where/how

Gemma Clayton

YES

15.09.22

Start to think about who to nominate as chair for next meeting – but can do at the next meeting

Group

YES

15.09.22

Structure of NHS national and locally

Gemma Clayton

YES

15.09.22

Agenda setting

Group

YES

15.09.22

Question re GP ratios

Gemma Clayton

O/S

07.12.22

To circulate criteria by which web developers get on to the preferred supplier list

Nina Graham

End of year attached to December email

07.12.22

To provide link to the GPAD data

Gemma Clayton

End of year attached to December email

07.12.22

Submit feedback to Trinity Medical re their website and new requests to go on the website

Group

End of Feb ‘23

07.12.22

Volunteer expertise, if available, re questionnaire design

Group

End of Jan ‘23

07.12.22

Volunteer as survey Guinea Pigs

Group

End of Jan ‘23

07.12.22

Circulate New Patient Pack from WellBN

Shilpa Patel

End of Jan ‘23

n/a pack is staff pack not patient pack

07.12.22

Follow up with Commissioners re updated “Roles in GP practice leaflet for Brighton”

Gemma Clayton

ongoing

Completed and attached to December email

07.12.22

Circulate next Meeting date

Gemma Clayton

End of year attached to December email

07.12.22

Circulate Minutes

Gemma Clayton

End of year attached to December email

Attendees

Face to Face

Practice

Teams

Practice

Subhash

Trinity – apologies

Paul

Charter

Erin

Trinity – apologies

Charlotte

WellBN

Mary

WellBN

David Tayor

WellBN

Keith

WellBN

Kate – Chair

Trinity

Nicola – Notes

Trinity

Leslie

Charter

Nina Graham

Charter

Shilpa Patel

WellBN

Amanda Jones

Trinity

Lindsay Coleman

WellBN

Fabia

Charter

Iain

WellBN – apologies

John

WellBN

Kay

WellBN

Lotita

WellBN

Sara

WellBN

Jackie

WellBN

Sarah

WellBN – asked to go on zoom call – but GC didn’t see email

Jeremy

WellBN

Peter

WellBN

May

WellBN

Bella

WellBN

Gemma Clayton

PCN Manager

 

Acronyms

Goldstone PCN – Goldstone Primary Care Network –

Since the NHS was created in 1948, the population has grown and people are living longer. Many people are living with long term conditions such as diabetes and heart disease or suffer with mental health issues and may need to access their local health services more often.

To meet these needs, GP practices are working together with community, mental health, social care, pharmacy, hospital and voluntary services in their local areas in groups of practices known as primary care networks (PCNs).

PCNs build on existing primary care services and enable greater provision of proactive, personalised, coordinated and more integrated health and social care for people close to home. Clinicians describe this as a change from reactively providing appointments to proactively caring for the people and communities they serve.

Each of the 1,250 PCNs across England are based on GP registered patient lists, typically serving natural communities of between 30,000 to 50,000 people (with some flexibility). They are small enough to provide the personal care valued by both people and GPs, but large enough to have impact and economies of scale through better collaboration between GP practices and others in the local health and social care system. Goldstone PCN is the biggest in Brighton with 78,000 patients.

PCNs are led by clinical directors who may be a GP, general practice nurse, clinical pharmacist or other clinical profession working in general practice and a PCN Manager/lead.

ARRS

Additional Roles Reimbursement Scheme (ARRS)

These staff support the PCNs working in a number of practices, see the leaflet attached in the email for more information about what the roles mean.

  • Clinical Pharmacist.
  • Pharmacy Technician.
  • Social Prescribing Link Worker.
  • Health and Wellbeing Coach.
  • Care Co-ordinator.
  • Physician Associate.
  • First Contact Physiotherapists.

Meeting Agenda 15th Spetmeber 2022

Goldstone Primary Care Network

Charter Medical Centre, Trinity Medical Centre and WellBN (Brighton Health & Wellbeing Centre and Benfield Valley Healthcare hub)

 

Patient Participation Community Group Agenda

Date: Wednesday 14th September

Time: 6.00pm – 8.00pm

Location: Trinity Medical Centre

 

 

Agenda

 

 

· Welcome to Goldstone Primary Care Network– 15 mins

 

· Questions – 5 mins

 

· Martyn Yeats – Introduction to Patient Participation Groups (PPGs)/Community group; what they are, what the roles are in a PPG that patients who volunteer take on, examples of things that the PPG have been involved in– 20 mins

 

· Questions – 5 mins

 

· Break for time to read the PPG /Community document / cup of tea / any volunteers if would like to be a chair /role in PPG – 30 mins

 

· Ideas for how we get interest in our PPG/Community group – 5 mins

 

· Practice Managers/Partners to talk through what happening in practices – 20 min

 

· Next steps – a chair/admin support/ next meeting/ action log /share contact details

Meeting Notes 15th September 2022

15.09.22 To send out email to group of attendees – to confirm next steps/Action plan Gemma Clayton
15.09.22 Agree date for next meeting where/how Gemma Clayton
15.09.22 Start to think about who to nominate as chair for next meeting – but can do at the next meeting Group
15.09.22 Structure of NHS national and locally Gemma Clayton
15.09.22 Agenda setting Group
15.09.22 Question re GP ratios Gemma Clayton